92 Days of Pizza

     Welcome to 2024! Here comes the 92 days of pizza! Did you know Indiana has 92 counties? We have asked our members about their favorite pizza places from each county. We will post our favorite pizza from each county one per day.


Adams | Allen | Bartholomew | Benton | Blackford | Boone | Brown | Carroll | Cass | Clark | Clay | Clinton | Crawford | Daviess | Dearborn | Decatur | De Kalb | Delaware | Dubois | Elkhart | Fayette | Floyd | Fountain | Franklin

Day #1 of #92daysofpizza Adams County, Indiana is our first stop in the 92 days of pizza. Our members nominated Famous Monster Pizza in Decatur, Indiana. Horror themed pizza joint. You can enjoy a great slice while watching a slasher! What is your favorite pizza from Adam’s County?

Day #2 of the #92daysofpizza takes us to Allen County, Indiana. This was a tough one! We traveled to Fort Wayne, Indiana a few years ago for pizza tour and had a TON of great pizza. Raimondo's Pizza, Lexy's Pizza - Leo Crossing, Johnny OX Pizzeria, and Redwood Inn Pizza to name a few, but my personal favorite and our winner for Allen County is Oley's Pizza. Its thick and cheesy just like me! What is your favorite pizza in Allen County? Fort Wayne Pizza Review - what did I miss?

Day #3 of the #92daysofpizza takes up to Bartholomew County, Indiana. If I go without the family, like trying new things so I've enjoyed going to the The Original Chicago's Pizza & Curry - Edinburgh IN but when I am with my family, we end going to the The Commons - playground and getting a pizza from ZwanzigZ Pizza & Brewing. Bacon Cheeseburger pizza, lasagna pizza, or classic peperoni are always a good choice!

Day #4 of the #92daysofpizza we travel to Benton County and pay homage to the King. Oxford Indiana has a great Pizza King. Jump off the highway, drive down 52, take in the scenery, and stop in from some crispy crumbles of peperoni!

Day #5 of the #92daysofpizza we travel to Blackford County. I have a college friend that lives near Harford City. When I visited they took me to a bowling alley to get pizza. I was a little skeptical at first, but The Pickle Lounge and Northside Lanes was a strike! We did try the pickle bacon pizza and none was sparred. If you are a pineapple pizza person, the Big Kahuana is also a great option.

Day #6 of the #92daysofpizza we travel to Boone County. To say I am in love with this place would be a cheesy pun but lets go with it. If you are in Boone County, make sure you try Amore Pizzeria and Ristorante. New York Style pizza done the Indiana way. You can walk up and order a slice to go. Fresh toppings and nice staff.

Day #7 of the #92daysofpizza we travel to Brown County. This is another tough choice! I've spent many days hiking the woods and visiting the shops. Brown County has several great pizza places like Stonehead pizza Co and Big Wood Pizza, but I have a soft spot for the garlic knots at Brozinnis Pizza. It’s a family tradition to do the Brown County Humane Society Chocolate walk and then grab lunch there. So good!

Day #8 of the #92daysofpizza we travel to Carroll County. If you are looking for a hot spot to grab a pizza, go to Flora, Indiana and try Fire Pizza. Quick service. I tried the taco pizza and it was great!

Day #9 of the #92daysofpizza we travel to Cass County. #Encanto tells us we don’t talk about Bruno, but on this day we do! Bruno's Pizza has been family owned and operated in Logansport Indiana since the 1960s. Don’t knock it till you try it, order the Dingo Dough – garlic parmesan cheese bread strips and a large Marge’s meat lover – I like to add jalapeno to mine. Great place and awesome family legacy.

Day #10 of the #92daysofpizza we travel to Clark County. When we started this hashtag, people started submitting their recommendations. We had at least a dozen people post that The Charlestown Pizza Company in Charlestown IN should be the winner for Clark County. I have not personally been there – YET – but after that overwhelming crowd support and stalking their page, I think its time for a road trip!

Day #11 of the #92daysofpizza we travel to Clay County. This is another fan submitted suggestion but its not on my bucket list to try. I hear people in Clay County are in love with L’oven Pizza in Brazil Indiana. I did some stalking, and it looks like they have a deep dish worth the drive and wings to die for. This will make it on my plate sometime in 2024!

Day #12 of the #92daysofpizza we travel to Clinton County. The center of the county may be called Frankfort, but these hot dogs know pizza. When I visit family in Frankfort we always go to the local Arni’s and get a pizza. Nothing can beat a thin crust and crispy pepperoni!

Day #13 of the #92daysofpizza we travel to Crawford County. On a road trip a while back I passed through the small town of Marengo Indiana on my way to visit the caves. By chance, we stopped and had a pizza at a place called Papenos Pizza. They were very nice and very generous with the toppings. If you find yourself in that area, it is worth stopping and sampling a local favorite.

Day #14 of the #92daysofpizza we travel to Daviess County. Several years ago, members of the Indiana Pizza Club went to Evansville for a Pizza Tour. On the way back, we stopped in Washington, Indiana and picked up two pizza and took them to East side Park for a picnic. We had a great afternoon with good friends, beautiful weather, and a great pizza from Jimbos pizza and wings Indiana really does have great pizza all over the state!

Day #15 of the #92daysofpizza we travel to Dearborn County. This was a tough call… My wife has family in Cincinnati, when we visit we stop and pizza. I have tried several pizza places in Lawrenceburg… Snappy Tomato, Buzzy’s NYPD but we go back to Strongs brick oven. Cant beat the crust!

Day #16 of the #92daysofpizza we travel to Decatur County. Pizza and beer are the adult version of peanut butter and jelly. They just go together perfectly. Greensburg Indiana has a great brewery called Tree City Brew. I went on a road trip to try the beer but loved the pizza. Go have a pint and a pie…you won’t be disappointed.

Day #17 of the #92daysofpizza we travel to DeKalb County. This was another tough call…. I went to college in northern Indiana and still have friends in the area. I debated on where to go. I love Rose Bros in Hamilton. Pizza Forum is a classic call. However, if I had to pick a winner for DeKalb County I am voting Coterie Pizza in Garrett Indiana. They have a brisket pizza that is amazing and a spicy cajun pizza that I dream of.

Day #18 of the #92daysofpizza we travel to Delaware County. A college town has some strong opinions about the best pizza. I may need some protection from the loyal pizza fans, but in my opinion, The Guardian Brewing Company has the best pizza in Muncie, Indiana. The purple hippo has a beer infused sauce! They also have a pickle pizza and a black and blue pizza.

Day #19 of the #92daysofpizza we travel to Dubois County. On a road trip to Santa Claus Indiana, I stopped in Huntingburg IN and tried pizza at Gaslight Pizza and Grill. I recommend the Gas pizza is their supreme and it is fully loaded with toppings!

Day #20 of the #92daysofpizza we travel to Elkhart County. Several Pizza Club members went to northern Indiana for a long weekend a few years ago. Over a 4-day weekend, we tried pizza from several places. On the trip, we voted and Venturi Neapolitan Pizza Pub was our number one pick. Incredible crust, great flavor, and my favorite pizza in Goshen Indiana. (MOD pizza, Vesuvio, and Miano’s were also amazing!)

Day #21 of the #92daysofpizza we travel to Fayette County. If you ever find yourself in Connersville, Indiana, you should head to Big Boyz pizza. Appetizers, salads, sandwiches, and great pizzas. I like the chicken alfredo pizza and Hawaiian – ham, pineapple, and banana pepper. Yes – pineapple on pizza is sometimes okay.

Day #22 of the #92daysofpizza we travel to Floyd County. I went back and forth with this decision. I’ve spent some time in New Albany Indiana. I like the pizza and beer from the New Albanian Brewing Company. Honorable mention to Legacy Pizza – they have a bacon Jam pizza that I do dream about.

Day #23 of the #92daysofpizza we travel to Fountain County. This place is a bit off the beaten path, but if you find yourself in Covington Indiana, you should look up Overpass Pizza. They have a great style. When I was there, the workers for nice and fun. The pizza was great and beer was cold.

Day #24 Today we travel to Franklin County, Indiana. I have not yet been to this place, but a member nominated it and now it is on my short list. I will have to travel to Batesville this spring to try Ison's Family Pizza. I was told the pies are amazing, they have an arcade, and I love a family owned and operated business.